Consignment shop ops

Pricing Consigned Items: Owner vs Consignor Authority

Quick answer

In a consignment shop, the shop should set prices and markdowns, not the consignor. Write the consignor's hoped-for price on the intake list, base the tag on similar items that sold in your own shop, and put a markdown calendar in the signed contract, for example full price for 30 days, 20% off after that, a further cut or pickup notice at 60 days, and return or donation at 90 days.

Faye let a consignor set the price on a dining table because the woman had "looked online" and wanted $1,800. The same table shape sat in Faye's shop, sold, at $650 the month before. The $1,800 table occupied a bay for 14 weeks. Two shoppers asked if the tag was a mistake. Faye could not mark it down without a text thread that went nowhere. The consignor owned the hope. Faye owned the floor space. Only one of those pays rent.

She changed the contract. The shop sets the price, including markdowns on a calendar the consignor hears before a tag exists. Their hope is written on the intake list so they feel heard. It is not the tag. The intake that makes this survivable is Onboarding Consignors: Contracts and Communication. A price policy that is not signed is a negotiation on the floor, in front of customers.

Who should set the price on consigned items?

The shop should set the opening price and the markdowns, and the consignor decides only whether to consign on those terms.

Decision Who Why
Opening price Shop Faye sees what actually sells in that room. A listing three states away is not the room
Consignor's hope Written down, not ticketed People need the number heard. The bay needs a number that can clear
Markdown date and percent Shop, on the calendar in the contract A text asking permission every two weeks is how the $1,800 table stayed
Refusal Either side, before intake If they will not accept shop pricing, the table does not come off their truck
A one-time exception Nobody, mid-contract One exception becomes the policy for the next person who overheard it

The split still matters, because a lower price changes their check. She does not pretend otherwise. She shows the math: a table at $650 that sells pays their percent. A table at $1,800 that sits pays zero, and it blocks a $650 table that would have. The percent itself is chosen with Setting Consignor Splits Fairly: A Shop Owner's Guide. Authority over the tag is not a sneak cut to the split. It is how the split ever gets multiplied by a sale.

What markdown schedule should a consignment shop use?

Use a fixed markdown calendar written into the contract. Faye's is: opening price for 30 days. Then 20% off, already printed as the rule, not as a surprise. At 60 days, another cut or a pickup notice. At 90 days the item goes home or to the donation line they initialed. She does not invent a new percent in the moment because a customer is waiting. The customer can buy what the calendar says today. If that is not low enough, the customer waits until the next date or buys something else.

Consignors get the sale notice and the payout on the cycle, not a phone call before each markdown. The cycle that made the calls stop is Consignor Payment Cycles: Weekly, Monthly, On-Sale. Mixing "call me before you drop it" with "pay me monthly" means she is running two businesses, and the phone one does not scale past a handful of relatives.

Reality Check: Some consignors will leave. Faye lost two when she stopped sharing the tag. Both had items that had not sold in a quarter. The bay they freed sold other people's goods inside three weeks. A full shop of unsold hopes is not a loyal clientele. It is storage.

How she sets the opening number

She uses the last similar item that sold in her shop, not the consignor's screenshot. If she has no comp, she prices at what she would put on it if she owned it, then tells them that number before unload. If they say no, the item stays on the truck. She would rather have an empty bay for a week than a hostage table for fourteen.

Staff are not allowed to "just this once" a tag to end a conversation. The counter checklist says shop price only. The same way unsigned goods do not get tagged, a consignor-written price does not get a tag either. Hope goes in the note. The note is not the sticker.

Pro Tip: Show them a sold tag from a similar piece, with the date, if you have one. A sold price from your floor ends more arguments than a speech about "the market."

What this does to the month

After the change, average days before a furniture sale dropped, and the awkward texts did too. She tracks days-on-floor the way a reseller tracks aging, because a consigned table that sits is the same profit leak as aged booth stock. The shape of that leak is in Inventory Aging: The Silent Profit Killer. The owner who cannot mark it down has chosen the leak on purpose.

The shop sets the price and the markdown dates. The consignor sets whether they want to participate. Write both down before the table comes through the door.

Frequently asked questions

Should consignors be allowed to set their own prices?

Letting consignors set their own prices usually leaves overpriced items occupying floor space for weeks. A consignment shop does better setting prices from what similar items actually sold for in that shop, while recording the consignor's hoped-for price on the intake list so the consignor feels heard.

How do I price a consigned item when I have no comparable sale?

When a consignment shop has no comparable sale of its own, a practical rule is to price the item at what you would charge if you owned it, then tell the consignor that number before the item is unloaded. If the consignor refuses the price, the item does not come into the shop.

Do I need consignor permission before marking an item down?

Not if the contract already sets the markdown dates and percentages. A markdown calendar signed at intake, such as 20% off after 30 days, lets staff reduce prices on schedule without calling the consignor, and the consignor sees the result in the sale notice and the regular payout.

Will lower prices reduce what consignors earn?

A lower tag reduces the consignor's share on that one sale, but an unsold item pays the consignor nothing. A $650 table that sells pays the consignor their split percentage, while an $1,800 table that sits for 14 weeks pays zero and blocks space for items that would have sold.

Put the markdown on the month's numbers

The P&L Template shows what sold after the cut versus what sat at the consignor's hope, so the bay has a cost.

Try the P&L Template
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google PlayUse Inventr in your web browser