Quick answer
A consignment shop should onboard each consignor with a signed contract before any item is tagged. The contract should state ownership, the split percentage and what it applies to, who sets prices and markdowns, the payout date, the unsold-goods pickup deadline (for example 14 days after notice) and damage terms. Run intake as a 15–30 minute meeting with an item list and damage photos, and have a local attorney review the contract.
Helen accepted a dining set on a handshake because the consignor was a neighbor and "everyone knows the split is 60/40." Eight weeks later the table sold, the neighbor believed the split was 70/30 because that is what another shop in town posts, and Helen spent a Sunday reconstructing a price from a text message. The set had netted enough to pay for a lawyer and instead it paid for an argument. She does not take items before the paper is signed anymore. The neighbor is still a neighbor. The next consignor gets the packet.
This is an operating checklist, not legal advice. Have a local attorney read the contract before you hand it to anyone. The points below are the ones that were missing when Helen's payout fights started.
What has to be true before a tag exists
A consignor is not onboarded when their items are on the floor. They are onboarded when you can answer, from a document they signed, who owns the goods, what percentage they receive, when they are paid, what happens if something does not sell, and what happens if it is damaged. Helen's shop will not print a tag until those answers are in the file.
The percentage itself is a separate decision from the paperwork. If you are still choosing the number, do that with the math in Setting Consignor Splits Fairly: A Shop Owner's Guide, then write the chosen number into the contract. A fair split that lives only in your head will be remembered differently by each household.
What should a consignment contract include?
A consignment contract should cover the parties, ownership, the split and what it applies to, pricing authority, payout timing, unsold goods, damage and theft, and how the relationship ends. Her attorney drafted the sentences. The topics are hers, because they map to fights she has already had. Your town's rules on bailment, sales tax, and abandoned property may add topics she does not have. That is the conversation with the attorney, not a paragraph to copy from a blog.
| Topic | What Helen fills in | The fight it prevented |
|---|---|---|
| Parties and contact | Legal name, mailing address, email, phone | "I never got the statement" sent to a number she did not have |
| Ownership | Consignor warrants they own the goods and may consign them | A family dispute that arrived after a sale |
| Split and what it applies to | Percent of the sold price, and whether tax and discounts come off first | The 60/40 versus 70/30 argument |
| Pricing authority | Shop sets the price, including markdowns after a stated number of days | A consignor who wanted last year's retail forever |
| Payout timing | Monthly, by the 10th, for sales cleared in the prior month | A demand to be paid from the parking lot |
| Unsold goods | Pickup within 14 days of notice, or a donation clause they initial | A back room of furniture nobody would collect |
| Damage and theft | What the shop does and does not cover, in plain language | A chip discovered at pickup, blamed on the floor |
| End of the relationship | Either side can end it, items due back on a date | A consignor who vanished and a floor that stayed full |
How should a consignment shop run a consignor intake meeting?
Treat intake as a scheduled meeting, not a drop-off: confirm the terms out loud, list and photograph every item, then sign before tagging. She books 30 minutes for a first consignor and 15 for a returning one with new items. The first meeting has a script so she does not skip the awkward parts when the person is charming.
- Walk the split, the markdown calendar, and the payout date out loud. Ask them to say the percentage back.
- Mark every item on an intake list: description, condition, their asking hope, and the price the shop will actually try. Hopes get written down so they are not forgotten. They do not become the ticket price.
- Photograph the item and any existing damage with the consignor present. The photo goes in the file. "It was already like that" is a sentence she can answer.
- Sign, give them a copy, and only then print tags.
The 30 minutes felt like overhead until she counted the Sunday she lost to the dining set. One avoided fight pays for a year of meetings.
Communication she sends without being asked
Helen used to wait for consignors to call. They called when they were already angry, which meant she was explaining a markdown that had happened three weeks earlier. She now sends three messages, all short, all from the same address so they do not look like marketing.
- The day items are tagged. Count of items and the date markdowns can start. No essay.
- The day after a sale. Item, sold price, their share, and the payout date. Not a payment. A preview, so the 10th is not a surprise.
- Fourteen days before she needs unsold goods picked up. The list, the deadline, and the donation sentence they already initialed.
She does not negotiate the split inside those emails. A one-off "just this once" becomes the new contract and it is not written down. If a consignor wants a different split, that is a new document, and it has to survive the same math as everyone else's. The cost of a special deal usually shows up in staff time, not in the percentage. Those hours belong in the same expense picture as rent. Operating Expenses Every Booth Seller Should Track is the list she uses so a "friendly" exception has a place to land on the P&L.
Who does not get onboarded
Helen declines items she cannot price, items she cannot move through the door, and consignors who want to approve every markdown in real time. She says no in the meeting, before the truck is unloaded. A no at the curb is awkward for five minutes. A no after the items are tagged is a storage problem with a witness.
She also declines anyone who will not sign the damage photos. In her first year that was two people. Both later described damage she is glad she did not own the story of.
When someone else runs intake
The packet failed the first Saturday Helen was not in the shop. A part-timer accepted four boxes, skipped the damage photos because the consignor was in a hurry, and printed tags so the floor would look full. One box included a lamp with a crack at the base. The crack became visible under the store lights on Monday. The consignor said it happened in the shop. Helen had no photo from the curb. She paid the share as if the lamp had sold intact, and she removed it. The part-timer had been trying to help.
Intake is now a checklist on the counter, six boxes, initialed by whoever did the meeting. No initials, no tags. The checklist is the same four steps as the meeting: split said back, intake list, damage photos, signature. New staff do two intakes with Helen present before they initial alone. Friendliness is not a step. The neighbor with the dining set was friendly.
She also stopped letting "I'll bring the contract back next time" hold a place on the floor. Items without a signature go home with the person who brought them, the same day. Storage "until they sign" filled a corner with other people's furniture and no payout rule attached. The corner is for priced goods. Unsigned goods are still a visit, not inventory.
The file she can pull in under a minute
Each consignor has one folder: the signed contract, the intake list, the damage photos, and the statement history. When someone calls about a table from April, she is not searching a group text. The folder is the business. The floor is just where the items wait.
Get the split, the payout date, the markdown rule, and the unsold-goods deadline signed before you print a tag, and send the sale notice before anyone has to ask where their money is.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use a consignment agreement template from the internet?
A downloaded consignment agreement template is a starting point, not a finished contract. Rules on bailment, sales tax and abandoned property vary by state, and a donation clause for unsold goods must match how your state treats property left behind. Have a local attorney review the agreement before consignors sign it.
Why should consignment shops photograph items at intake?
Photographing each consigned item and any existing damage with the consignor present creates a record for later disputes. When a crack or chip is noticed after the item is on the floor, the intake photo shows whether the damage was already there, so the shop does not end up paying for damage it did not cause.
What should a consignment shop do with unsold items?
A consignment contract should give consignors a set pickup window after notice, such as 14 days, and state what happens next, often a donation clause the consignor initials at signing. Send a reminder listing the unsold items and the deadline so the back room does not fill with goods nobody collects.
What messages should a consignment shop send consignors?
A consignment shop can head off most payout calls with three short messages: one when items are tagged (item count and markdown start date), one the day after each sale (item, price, their share and payout date), and one before the unsold-goods pickup deadline.
