Quick answer
Sell commodity books with an ISBN on Amazon when you are allowed to list them and the price clears your floor. Sell books whose value is the jacket, plates, signature or binding, or that Amazon restricts, on eBay with photos. Use Etsy only for attractive books at least 20 years old, Etsy's vintage minimum. eBay's Books & Magazines final value fee is 15.3% of the total sale up to $7,500, plus a per-order fee.
Jules scanned a box of 40 books at an estate sale, listed the whole box on Amazon because the app was already open, and spent the next month answering "why is this restricted" on half of them. The cookbooks with stained jackets wanted a different buyer than the textbook. The 1960s illustrated volume wanted photos. Amazon wanted an ISBN and a condition note and then held the listing anyway.
eBay, Amazon, and Etsy can all sell a book. They do not want the same book. Jules's sort takes about a minute a copy once the rules are written down. Fee figures below are the assumptions she used that season. Pull the current rate from each platform before you price from this table.
How do book buyers differ on eBay, Amazon and Etsy?
Each platform's book buyer wants a different copy. Amazon's book buyer is often comparing your copy to a row of the same ISBN. You win on price, condition, and whether you are allowed to sell that title at all. eBay's buyer will read a title and look at photos, which matters when the ISBN is missing or the value is the dust jacket, the signature, or the plates. Etsy's buyer is shopping vintage as an object. A book has to be old enough to be listed there, and it has to look like something a person puts on a shelf on purpose.
If you are still deciding whether scanning is worth the time at all, start with Scanning Books for Resale: Which Apps Actually Pay Off?. The scan tells you a rank and a price band. It does not tell you the channel.
Where her last 32 sold copies went
She tracked one ten-week stretch after she stopped dumping every copy into Amazon. Thirty-two of those copies sold. The rest in the table are the ones she listed and then gave up on, because a channel decision includes the books that refuse the channel. "Net" is sale price minus what she paid, minus the fee she recorded, minus outbound postage she ate. Buyer-paid postage is not in the net. Days are listing to sale.
| Kind of book | Channel | Copies | Typical net | Typical days |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Recent ISBN, unrestricted, rank she trusts | Amazon | 14 | $6 to $11 | 9 to 20 |
| Textbook she was gated out of | eBay, after Amazon refused | 3 | $18 to $27 | 14 to 30 |
| No ISBN, book-club fiction | eBay, then mostly unsold | 2 sold, 8 donated | About $4 | 40 |
| Pre-1980 illustrated, intact jacket | eBay | 7 | $22 to $48 | 12 to 25 |
| Pre-1980 illustrated, she also tried Etsy | Etsy | 4 | $19 to $36 | 18 to 40 |
| Pretty but common 1990s cookbook | Neither Etsy nor a patient Amazon | 6 unsold on Amazon, 2 sold on eBay | $5 | 21 on eBay |
The pattern she kept: Amazon for the commodity ISBN she is allowed to sell. eBay for anything that needs a photograph or a permission Amazon will not give. Etsy only for copies old enough to pass the vintage rule and attractive enough that a photo is the product.
How do you decide which platform to sell a book on?
Run four questions in order, in about a minute per copy:
- Is there an ISBN, and will Amazon let her sell it? If the scan shows a price she wants and the listing is not restricted, it goes to Amazon. She does not photograph commodity paperbacks. The buyer's row of offers will not reward the photo.
- If Amazon blocks it or the scan price is a race to $4, does the book have a face? A jacket, plates, a binding, an inscription she can describe without overclaiming. That copy goes to eBay with three photos: front, title page, the flaw.
- Is it old enough for Etsy, and would she put it on her own shelf? If both are yes, she lists it on Etsy or eBay, not both on day one. She picks the channel where her last similar copy sold. Cross-listing the same scarce book on day one is how she once sold it twice.
- If none of those fire, it does not come home. Book-club fiction with no jacket failed this test eight times. She donates at the sale now.
Fees change the $12 book more than the $40 book
A $12 paperback with a thick fee and a label she subsidizes can net less than the quarter she paid. A $40 illustrated book can absorb a higher percentage and still pay for the photo time. Jules stopped asking which platform is "cheaper" and started asking which platform can clear her floor of $6 net after postage she pays. Under that floor, the book is a hobby she did not mean to fund.
The fee comparison she uses when a copy could honestly live on more than one site is Platform Fee Comparison: eBay vs Poshmark vs Mercari for the habit of writing fees down, plus the bookseller rate card on Amazon and eBay's own fee page. Poshmark is rarely her book channel. The discipline of writing the fee before the price is the part that transfers.
Photos, ranks, and the lies each site tells
Amazon's rank tells her there is a market for that ISBN. It does not tell her she will be the one who sells it if twelve sellers are already at the same price. She skips a rank she likes when the lowest offer is already under her floor. eBay's sold comps lie in the other direction: one wild result from a signed copy will talk her into a price her unsigned copy cannot get. She requires two sold comps that match the edition in her hand.
Etsy tells her almost nothing in search volume for a specific title. It tells her whether the object is pleasant. She lists fewer books there, with better photos, and she does not send Etsy the stained book-club copies just to "have them up."
Condition notes that belong to the channel
Amazon's condition grades are a promise to a buyer comparing ten copies of one ISBN. Jules uses the grade she can defend from the book's own help text, and she under-grades when she is unsure. A "very good" that arrives looking "good" costs more in a return than the extra two dollars she tried to capture. eBay will tolerate a longer note and a photo of the torn page, so the illustrated copies get the tear in photo three and in the first line. Etsy buyers in her experience forgive wear that looks like age and do not forgive a smell she hoped the description could skip. If a book smells like the garage it came from, it does not go to Etsy. It goes to eBay with the smell stated, or it does not come home.
She writes the note before she photographs, from the book in her hand, not from memory after the photo pile. Memory upgrades condition. The book does not.
A weekly cap so the sort survives Saturday
Jules lists no more than 15 books in a session. The cap is what keeps step four honest. Without it, the unsold fiction comes home because the box is already in the car. Fifteen is enough to include the illustrated copies that pay for the trip and the ISBN copies Amazon can move. It is not enough to include charity.
Put the commodity ISBN on Amazon if you are allowed to sell it and the price clears your floor. Put the book that needs a face on eBay. Put it on Etsy only when it is old enough and you would be willing to show the jacket up close.
Frequently asked questions
Can you sell used books on Etsy?
Only in limited cases. Etsy's vintage policy says an item must be at least 20 years old to be listed as vintage, so in 2026 a book printed in 2006 or earlier can qualify. Newer used books that are simply resold commercial products do not fit Etsy's rules, and Etsy may ask sellers how they determined an item's age.
What does eBay charge to sell a book?
eBay's fee page lists a final value fee of 15.3% for Books & Magazines on the total sale amount up to $7,500 per item, plus 2.35% on any portion above $7,500. eBay also charges a per-order fee of $0.30 on orders of $10 or less and $0.40 on orders over $10.
What do Amazon's used book condition grades mean?
Amazon's guidance says Used - Like New books may have light cosmetic issues but clean pages and an intact dust cover; Very Good allows minor wear; Good requires all pages and the cover intact, with limited notes or highlighting allowed; and Acceptable can show heavy wear or minor water damage as long as the text stays readable.
Should I list the same book on eBay, Amazon and Etsy at the same time?
For scarce single copies, it is safer to list on one platform first, chosen by where a similar copy last sold. Cross-listing one book on several sites on day one risks selling it twice and cancelling an order. Common ISBN copies belong on Amazon, and photo-driven copies usually start on eBay.
Sources: Etsy: Vintage items on Etsy; eBay Help: Selling fees; Amazon: What are Amazon condition guidelines?. Last reviewed October 2026.
