Quick answer
To handle eBay Best Offers profitably, write a floor price for each listing before it goes live: item cost plus expected fees, absorbed shipping and a few dollars for your time. Accept any offer at or above the floor, send one counter at the floor when an offer is within about 15% below it, and decline lower offers without countering. If you use auto-accept, set it at the floor.
Diane accepted a $41 offer on a $78 coat because the phone buzzed during school pickup and tapping Accept was faster than thinking. After fees and the $19 she had paid, the coat cleared about $6. She had listed it to clear $28. Best Offer did not steal the money. An unwritten floor did.
She now answers from three templates, chosen by where the offer sits against a floor she writes before the listing goes up. The words are short on purpose. eBay buyers rarely read a paragraph, and a paragraph is where she used to apologize her price down.
How do you set a Best Offer floor on eBay?
Add your item cost, the eBay fees expected at that price, any shipping you absorb, and a small amount for your time. For every listing she writes one number: the least she will accept today. It is cost, plus the fees she expects on that price, plus shipping she is eating, plus $8 for her time. If that number is above what sold comps support, the item does not get Best Offer. It gets a lower list price or a different channel. A floor the market will not pay is not a strategy. It is a wish.
The store subscription and the ad rate are separate bills. She settles those in eBay Store vs No Store: When the Subscription Actually Pays and does not "make it back" by caving on an offer. An offer below the floor declines. She does not counter a number she would not take, because a counter teaches the buyer that the floor was fake.
How should you reply to an eBay Best Offer?
Accept offers at or above your floor, counter once at the floor when an offer is within 15% below it, and decline anything lower without a counter. List price is the anchor. Floor is the stop. Everything in between is a counter. These are the replies she pastes, with the dollar amounts swapped in.
| Offer vs her floor | What she does | Message |
|---|---|---|
| At or above the floor | Accept | No message. Accepting fast matters more than a thank-you. |
| Within 15% under the floor | One counter, at the floor | "I can do $[floor]. That includes the [flaw already in the listing]." |
| More than 15% under the floor | Decline, no counter | She used to counter these. The buyer almost never met her, and the thread wasted a day. |
| Second offer, still under the floor | Decline | "$[floor] is the lowest I can go on this one." Then she stops replying. |
The 15% is her number, not eBay's. A $70 floor treats $60 as a conversation and $48 as a no. She does not invent a mid-point to seem flexible. The floor is the counter.
What 40 offers did in September
She logged 40 Best Offers on clothing and small housewares. List prices were comps, not fantasies. Floors were written.
- 11 offers at or above the floor: accepted. Average gap under list price was $9. Those were the point of turning Best Offer on.
- 14 offers within 15%: one counter each. 9 buyers took the floor. 5 went quiet. She did not chase.
- 15 offers more than 15% under: declined with no counter. Two buyers came back later at the floor on their own. The other 13 did not.
Net of the accepted and the countered sales beat her old habit of accepting anything within $15, because the old habit had included four sales under the floor that wiped out the "easy yes" feeling. She stopped measuring herself by how fast the offer folder emptied.
Messages she retired
"Would you consider..." invited a second low number. "I paid more than that" is not the buyer's problem, and it starts a fight. "Price is firm" on a listing with Best Offer enabled is a contradiction. If the price is firm, she turns Best Offer off. The setting is the policy. The message should not argue with the setting.
She also stopped explaining fees in the counter. Buyers do not owe her the fee table. The floor already contains the fees. The sentence that mentions the flaw works better, because it reminds them the price includes the condition they can see.
When Best Offer should be off
Unique pieces with tight comps do not need a negotiation widget. Diane turns it off when the last three sold comps sit in a $5 band and her list price is already at the low end. She turns it on for items with a wide comp range, and for anything older than 30 days that she is willing to walk down to the floor without a public price cut. A public cut resets the listing's story. A private floor does not.
Offers are not profit. The sale after fees is. The distinction is the whole point of Why Revenue Isn't Profit, and it is easy to forget when a green Accept button is waiting.
Write the floor before you publish, accept anything at or above it, counter once at the floor when they are close, and decline the rest without a speech.
Frequently asked questions
How do eBay Best Offer auto-accept and auto-decline work?
eBay Best Offer lets a seller set two private price limits: offers at or above the auto-accept amount are accepted automatically, and offers below the auto-decline amount are declined automatically. Buyers cannot see either limit, and the auto-accept amount must be below the Buy It Now price. Setting auto-accept at your profit floor prevents accidental low sales.
Should I counter every lowball offer on eBay?
No. Countering an eBay offer far below your floor rarely produces a sale and teaches the buyer that your floor is negotiable. A practical rule is to counter once, at the floor, only when the offer is within about 15% of it, and to decline lower offers with no counter.
Should I write "price is firm" on an eBay listing with Best Offer turned on?
No. Writing "price is firm" on an eBay listing that has Best Offer enabled contradicts the listing's own setting and invites argument. If the price really is firm, turn Best Offer off; if it is on, let the floor price and your reply templates do the negotiating.
When should I turn Best Offer off on eBay?
Turn Best Offer off when recent sold comps sit in a narrow band and your list price is already at the low end of it. Best Offer is most useful on items with a wide range of sold prices, and on older listings you are willing to sell down to the floor without a public price cut.
Sources: eBay Help: Adding Best Offer to your listing. Last reviewed October 2026.
